Thirty-third Sunday in Ordinary Time 2026

Probably, John Calvin invented capitalism. I really hope there are no economic historians here…

Hear me out. Once upon a time, Christians were strongly opposed to the business of the lending of money for interest. The Hebrew Bible is broadly negative on the thing, though it carves out an exception for doing it to foreigners. Luke’s Gospel asks,  rhetorically, “And if you lend to those from whom you hope to receive, what credit is that to you?”; and he proceeds, “But love your enemies, and do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return”.

The Church Fathers also frowned upon usury: Basil thought it exploitative as did Gregory of Nyssa, and Ambrose figured it tantamount to robbery. The Fathers were not especially nuanced on the matter: they were outraged at the very idea that anyone would want to profit from other people’s financial needs. 

Things got a bit more sophisticated in the middle ages, but Thomas Aquinas still thought interested money-lending unnatural, an abomination against the meaning of money and property. Luther similarly argued that it was a violation against nature, this time of human relationships. Then comes John Calvin, that famed moral relativist, to say that whether or not usury is sinful depends on a variety of factors; it’s complicated, and sometimes it’s OK. Thus, John Calvin: patron saint of high finance. 

Except, of course, that there had by that point been centuries of banking in Christendom. The Medicis, Bardis, and Peruzzis of the world made their fortunes in part from money-lending, with interest being disguised  in various ways, sometimes as gifts, sometimes as rent on collateral, sometimes as profit-sharing, sometimes as pre-arranged penalties for late repayment. And we—who love Western art and architecture—are the cultural beneficiaries of the Florentine sophistry that alleges to abide by the letter of the prohibition against usury, while running roughshod on its spirit. 

Calvin’s contribution was to render unnecessary these mechanisms for usury-avoidance: he argued that the Bible prohibited the uncharitable exploitation of debtors, not interest as such. This is not to say that he advocated for an unfettered and unregulated banking sector—he was too…Calvinist…for that.

+++

And yet, we have here, in Matthew’s Gospel, what seems at least like a tolerance of interest, if not indeed an enthusiastic embrace of it. The third servant is chastised for the poor return on investment of the initial capital, and advised to stick it in the bank to accrue interest. 

The dominant meaning of the English word “talent” is clue enough for how this parable has been interpreted. This is where it comes from, of course: talanton, being 6,000 denarii—well over a decade’s worth of  basic wages. Almost everyone reads this text as encouragement to be good stewards of all that God has given us. In the early and medieval Church, these were mainly identified as the gospel itself, or the teachings of Christ, or other spiritual gifts. More recently, the focus changed to the skills and abilities to which we are disposed; our talents. But the text has also been used to justify a regulated usury: by the 18th century, Christians had taken Calvin’s challenge against the ancient and medieval view and run with it. Certainly, it seemed obvious to the Scottish Roman Catholic Bishop George Hay that the parable of the talents was an endorsement of money-lending: he wrote that “interest is the soul of credit and credit is the soul of commerce”. 

But this is, upon inspection, an odd way to read this text. The Master has not given anyone any gifts here. The more natural reading is that the Master has instructed his slaves to make him even richer than he already is. It is not clear what profit margin he was expecting, though: 0% was clearly unacceptable, and 100% clearly commendable. All this sits awkwardly amongst the other teachings of Jesus about money. Elsewhere in Matthew’s Gospel, we are warned against accumulating and hoarding wealth: we are told that we cannot serve both God and Mammon. And that it is most difficult for the rich to enter the kingdom of heaven, who should sell their possessions for the sake of the blessed poor.

This suggests a reading of the parable that is, admittedly, as far as I know, a departure from the tradition: that maybe it is the third slave who turns out to be our hero, who resists the demands of the ruling class, refusing to participate in the usurious system in which money begets money not by magic but at least in part—perhaps even in large part—by the exploitation of those on the wrong side of wealth inequality. This slave who renders to this monied Master what belongs to him, no more and no less; but this demonstrably does not include his ultimate obedience and allegiance, or even the due respect of penitential silence, as we see from his impertinent little speech. And for this insolent refusal of complicity, the slave is cast out, ostracised by the rich and powerful, disgraced in the darkness.

+++

Money and its systems have changed beyond recognition since the time of Calvin, of the Medicis, Bardis, and Peruzzis, of Aquinas, of Basil, Gregory, and Ambrose, and certainly of the first century. I cannot pretend to understand how it all works nowadays, except to say that it now seems impossible to truly escape from the financial world, which is increasingly just coextensive with the world proper. 

The bold choice of checking out of the modern financial system is, for most of us, practically unavailable. Most of us have or have had loans of some kind: student loans, car loans, housing loans, all of the above. Most of us also benefit in some way—even if very meagrely—from interest-generating financial instruments, from savings accounts to pension pots. And we believe, probably accurately, that pulling our assets out of such devices would be very bad for us in the future, what with the rate of inflation. The church too—this one, and certainly the Church of England, with its £11.6 billion endowment that reaps average of 9.2% in annual returns. 

And even if the days of asking whether it is a violation of natural law for money to beget money are over, surely we must still ask whether our participation in financialised capitalism is in any way harmful, whether it is extractive or exploitative, whether it is corrupt or corrupting. That question is increasingly difficult to answer, as it grows increasingly opaque where interest and dividends and capital growth come from. I don’t really know what the people over at Barclays do with my money that allows them to deliver me 3.96% AER, but their regular appearances on the news are not encouraging. It is otherwise tempting simply to put our faith in ESG ratings or some other ostensibly ethical benchmarks, without asking too many questions about who sets those benchmarks and on what moral foundations—but I wonder if we would like the answers we might find. 

We are called naïve, who have our moral and theological scruples about all this, who wring our hands if not quite gnash our teeth over our investment—our investedness—in this world of portfolios and profits that surpass certainly my understanding. But I can’t shake the feeling that there is something we might learn from the naïveté of that third slave.

Next
Next

Remembrance Sunday